Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

$

Truth-O-Meter checks items on Menendez support of taxes; 1980 Reagan, Carter race

By Caryn Shinske
October 2, 2012

Taxes and claims of a comeback were at the center of weekend items on the Truth-O-Meter, but neither focused on Gov. Chris Christie’s Jersey Comeback.

In case you missed it, the Truth-O-Meter on Sunday handed down a Mostly False to state Sen. Joe Kyrillos for a claim about higher taxes. Christie received a Half True ruling on Monday for his claim about the 1980 presidential debate between Ronald Reagan and Jimmy Carter.

Kyrillos claim

The Monmouth County Republican said in an Aug. 29 news release that incumbent U.S. Sen. Bob Menendez, a Democrat, voted in favor of higher taxes more than 70 times. We reviewed a list of 72 votes from 2006 to 2011 sent to us by the Kyrillos campaign and found that more than half of the votes had no effect on tax policy or law, or were procedural matters. Menendez did vote in favor of higher taxes on several occasions, but not nearly as often as the Kyrillos campaign claimed.

Christie claim

The governor said in late September that Reagan trailed Carter in the 1980 polls but after their televised presidential debate, Reagan went on to win 40 states. Reagan actually won 44 states, but there’s no clear evidence that the former governor of California trailed Carter. In fact, a number of polls at the time showed Reagan behind or ahead of Carter but given the margins of error in those polls, the two politicians were in a virtual dead heat going into the Oct. 28, 1980 debate.

To comment on this story, go to NJ.com.

Our Sources

PolitiFact New Jersey, Joe Kyrillos campaign claims Bob Menendez voted in favor of higher taxes more than 70 times, Sept. 30, 2012

PolitiFact New Jersey, Chris Christie claims Ronald Reagan won 40 states after trailing Jimmy Carter in polls leading up to their 1980 debate, Oct. 1, 2012

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Caryn Shinske
Chris Christie
stated on January 14, 2014 a State of the State address:
"Today, our unemployment rate is 7.8 percent. That is the lowest in five years."
Mostly True
David Rible
stated on November 30, 2013 an interview on NJTV's 'On the Record' with Michael Aron program:
"This governor has given us continual balanced budgets without raising taxes."
Half-True
Chris Christie
stated on December 2, 2013 response to subpoenas being sent out over a bridge lane-closure controversy:
"The fact that one town has three lanes dedicated to it, that kind of gets me sauced."
Pants on Fire!
Loretta Weinberg
stated on November 14, 2013 an interview on the John Gambling radio program:
"We pay among the highest tolls in the nation for the privilege of crossing that bridge."
True
Chris Christie
stated on November 10, 2013 interviews on four Sunday morning news shows:
Says New Jersey has gained "143,000 new private-sector jobs."
True
Chris Christie
stated on November 2, 2013 a response to a public school teacher:
"In fact, there’s more state funding for education today than any other time."
True
Chris Christie
stated on October 21, 2013 a gubernatorial campaign TV ad:
Says Barbara Buono "voted to raise her own pay 40 percent."
Mostly True
Milly Silva
stated on October 7, 2013 a speech to an American Legion in Little Ferry:
"Property taxes have increased 20 percent under four years of Chris Christie."
Mostly True
Kim Guadagno
stated on October 8, 2013 a speech to supporters in Carlstadt:
Chris Christie "has not increased the taxes on anyone."
Half-True
Steve Lonegan
stated on September 23, 2013 an interview on the John Gambling radio program:
"I would be the first Republican senator elected in New Jersey in 41 years."
True
Barbara Buono
stated on August 23, 2013 a speech to students at the Rutgers New Brunswick campus:
Tuition at Rutgers has increased 10 percent since Gov. Chris Christie took office because he "cut funding for higher education."
Half-True
Cory Booker
stated on September 10, 2013 an e-mailed campaign letter:
Newark is "now home to one-third of all commercial and multi-family development."
Half-True

Truth-O-Meter checks items on Menendez support of taxes; 1980 Reagan, Carter race





Donald Trump
stated on May 4, 2026 a White House event:








Donald Trump
stated on April 23, 2026 remarks at the White House:







Chris Wright
stated on April 19, 2026 an interview on CNN's "State of the Union":