Video of Harris calling a voter while the camera app is open does not prove she faked a call

Read in Spanish
Kamala Harris at phone bank in Washington, 11/5/2024
Democratic presidential nominee Vice President Kamala Harris, right, greets volunteers as she prepares to phone bank at the DNC headquarters on Election Day, Nov. 5, 2024, in Washington. (AP)

Vice President Kamala Harris made a surprise visit to a Washington, D.C., Democratic National Committee phone bank on Election Day. Harris was handed a phone to speak with a voter, a moment that went viral as social media users questioned the interaction.

An Instagram user shared the clip of Harris with the caption, “#KamalaHarris pretends to talk to voter on the phone, forgets she’s FAKING IT and holds her phone up, revealing her CAMERA APP open.”

False claim Harris staged call, 11/05/24
Figure 1: False claim Harris staged call, 11/05/24

(Screenshot from Instagram.)

The video was flagged as part of Meta’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Meta, which owns Facebook, Instagram and Threads.)

The clip went viral with Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., and former President Donald Trump’s son Eric Trump reposting it on X saying it shows that Harris faked the phone call.

In the full video Harris is handed a phone that she answers by saying, “Alexandria, it’s Kamala Harris … Have you voted already? You did, thank you!” The audience erupts in applause and Harris faces the phone towards the crowd, showing that the camera app is open.

But the clip is not proof that the phone call was staged, as social media users said. iPhones can run other apps during a call, according to the iPhone user guide for operating systems 12 to 18.

We tried it ourselves on an iPhone and successfully made a call while the camera app was open.

In the rest of the full video, Harris talks to other voters on speaker phone. Other people’s voices can be heard while the phone app is open.

We rate the claim that a video of Harris talking to a voter on the phone is fake because the camera app was on False.

PolitiFact Staff Writer Maria Ramirez Uribe contributed to this report.

Truth-o-meter Ruling

False

If your time is short

  • iPhones can run other apps during a call, according to iPhone user guides for operating systems 12 to 18.

  • In the rest of the full video, Harris talks to other voters on speaker phone, other people’s voices can be heard while the phone app is open. 

  • We tried it ourselves on an iPhone and found that we could make a call with the camera app open.

Statement

A video of Vice President Kamala Harris talking to a voter on the phone is fake because the camera app was on while she was on the call.

Context

Instagram posts

Speaker/Target

Statement Date

November 5, 2024
Our Sources

Instagram post (archived), Nov. 5, 2024

X post (archived), Nov. 5, 2024

X post (archived), Nov. 5, 2024

PBS News, WATCH: Harris meets supporters, makes calls at DNC phone bank on Election Day, Nov. 5, 2024

iPhone User Guide, While on a call on iPhone, accessed Nov. 6, 2024

More by This Author

Latest Fact-Checks