Image of Colombian protester is falsely described as example of Iranian torture of women


POF logo
Pants on Fire goes to claims rated false and ridiculous.

A viral image recently posted to Facebook of a woman buried in the ground up to her neck sipping a spoonful of water is misleading users to believe it was taken in Iran, just before the woman was to be stoned to death.

Text just below the photo reads: “A woman just before being stoned to death in Iran under Shariah laws. At some places on this earth, women’s rights are limited to getting a spoonful of water before stoning. Still want to tell me that Islam is worthy of being part of our civilization?”

The post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)

The photo is not doctored, but the message is far off. It is completely unrelated to Iran, Islam or stoning.

A reverse-image search of the photograph reveals it started to appear in the meme in 2018. The search also shows that  it was not captured in Iran but in Cali, Colombia, in July 2003.

The photo is part of a series taken by various news agencies, like Reuters, and depicts Maria Gabriela Ruiz, a 66-year-old Colombian woman who was one of three people protesting the Colombian government’s failure to relocate 150 displaced people to a safer sector of the city of Cali, according to one caption. Ruiz and others protested by voluntarily burying themselves up to their necks in July 2003, as was documented by photographs of the protests, which are available on Getty Images and Adobe’s stock images.

This isn’t to say that Iran hasn’t been criticized for its forms of punishment, which still include stoning as a legal method.

The photograph is real but has nothing to do with Islam, Sharia law or stoning, as social media’s false caption suggests. This post is Pants on Fire!

Share the Facts
1
1
7

PolitiFact rating logo PolitiFact Rating:

Pants on Fire

An image of a woman buried up to her neck and drinking a spoonful of water was from Iran and taken just before she was “stoned to death” under Sharia Law.
Friday, April 19, 2019

By
April 23, 2019

Truth-o-meter Ruling

Pants on Fire!

Statement

An image of a woman buried up to her neck and drinking a spoonful of water was from Iran and taken just before she was "stoned to death" under Sharia Law.

 

Context

a Facebook post

Speaker/Target

Speaker: Viral image

Statement Date

April 19, 2019
Our Sources

Facebook post, April 19, 2019

TinEye, Reverse-image search, April 22, 2019

Getty Images, A boy caresses his grandmother's head (photo), July 4, 2003

Adobe stock images, THREE COLOMBIAN PROTESTERS BURIED UP TO THEIR NECKS IN CALI, July 4, 2003

Hoax-alert.LeadStories, Fake News: NOT A Photo Of Woman In Iran Being Given Spoonful Of Water Before Being Stoned To Death, Aug. 4, 2018

FactCheck AFP, No, this picture does not show a Muslim woman about to be stoned to death, Jan. 15, 2019

New Yorker, War of Words: A woman’s battle to end stoning and juvenile execution in Iran, Dec. 27, 2015

Translations

Language: en

More by This Author

Latest Fact Checks