C-SPAN didn’t air ‘single person clapping’ caption during JD Vance’s speech


Sen. J.D. Vance, R-Ohio, at RNC, 07-17-24
Republican vice presidential candidate Sen. J.D. Vance, R-Ohio, stands on stage July 17, 2024, after speaking at the third day of the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee. (AP)

Republican vice presidential nominee JD Vance addressed supporters Aug. 21 at a campaign rally in Asheboro, North Carolina. The Ohio senator’s remarks were widely covered and shared in the media, including on C-SPAN, which aired Vance’s speech. 

A screenshot of that broadcast is circulating on social media with a purported subtitle knocking Vance: “(single person clapping).”

“LMAO @cspan caption person for the win,” said one Aug. 28 X post sharing the image. 

“Even closed captioning doesn’t like JV Vance,” another said. 

“Is there a Pulitzer for subtitles?” a third said. 

But C-SPAN aired no such caption, Robin Newton, a spokesperson for the network said. 

“We checked out captioning log,” Newton said. “That image is fake. It never appeared on C-SPAN.” 

A time stamp is visible in the image — 10:10 am PT — and we found the precise moment that appears in the screenshot, at about the 16:25 mark of this video on C-SPAN’s website. Vance was connecting his opponent, Democratic vice presidential nominee Tim Walz, the Minnesota governor, to China and saying voters need to elect former President Donald Trump back into office. A few seconds later, around the 16:28 mark, a caption appears that says, “(cheers and applause).”

We rate claims that C-SPAN aired the caption “single person clapping” False.

Truth-o-meter Ruling

False

If your time is short

  • C-SPAN didn’t air this caption, a spokesperson for the network said. 

Statement

C-SPAN captions for a JD Vance speech said, “Single person clapping.”

Context

an X post

Speaker/Target

Speaker: X posts
Targets: JD Vance

Statement Date

August 28, 2024
Our Sources

X post, Aug. 28, 2024

X post, Aug. 28, 2024

X post, Aug. 28, 2024

C-SPAN, Senator JD Vance Campaigns in North Carolina, Aug. 21, 2024

Email interview with Robin Newton, media relations specialist, C-SPAN, Aug. 29, 2024

 

More by This Author

Latest Fact-Checks