President Donald Trump parried an attack on his COVID-19 track record with an attack of his own on Democratic nominee Joe Biden.
“Joe, you’ve had 308,000 military people dying because you couldn’t provide them proper health care in the military,” Trump said Sept. 29 at the first presidential debate. “So don’t tell me about this.”
The claim stems from the 2014 debacle at several VA hospitals, where veterans were found to have died waiting to have their benefits approved to receive care. After news of the scandal broke, lawmakers asked the inspector general to investigate the scale of the VA application backlog and the deaths that resulted.
Investigators found a data system in chaos. The problems included:
-
In 2014, the VA’s database contained applications for people who died before 1998.
-
In the course of moving millions of records around in 2013, the VA inadvertently created enrollment entries for people “who never sought care or applied for enrollment.”
-
The database included anyone who had any contact with the VA, including people “whose military service has not been confirmed, qualified family members, employees participating in the employee health program, or patients receiving humanitarian care.”
To the point of Trump’s claim, the inspector general was able to match Social Security death records with over 307,000 applications listed as pending, but that included people who might never have applied or been eligible for care. In any event, 84% of the total died before 2010, the Obama-Biden administration’s second year.
Investigators described the VA’s enrollment system as “virtually unreliable.”
We reached out to the Trump campaign. While they had directed Factcheck.org to the inspector general’s report, they did not respond to our query.
Our ruling
Trump said that 308,000 military people died on Biden’s watch because he “couldn’t provide them proper health care in the military.”
Trump’s number is inaccurate. The report behind the figure includes people long dead who might never have applied for VA benefits and who might not have been in the military at all.
We rate this claim False.
Truth-o-meter Ruling
IF YOUR TIME IS SHORT
-
The number comes from a VA inspector general report that found the VA’s data "virtually unreliable."
-
The figure includes people who had been dead for many years, some before 1998.
-
It includes people who never applied for benefits.
Statement
Context
the first 2020 presidential debateSpeaker/Target
Statement Date
Our Sources
Rev, First 2020 presidential debate, Sept. 29, 2020
Department of Veterans Affairs Office of Inspector General, Veterans Health Administration: Review of Alleged Mismanagement at the Health Eligibility Center, Sept. 2, 2015
Factcheck.org, FactChecking the First Trump-Biden Debate, Sept. 30, 2020
Translations
Language: en