He’s off, way off on who’s in prison


In a debate at the historically black college, Gravel said, “one of the areas that touches me the most and enrages me the most is our war on drugs that this country has been putting forth for the last generation.”

Then he put forth statistics. 2.3 million people in jail. 70 percent of them African-American. Yikes. He got the first one right, but that 70 percent figure? That’s not just wrong, that’s Pants-On-Fire wrong. The real figure, according to the June 2007 report of the Bureau of Justice Statistics that counts federal, state and local jails, is 40 percent.

We’re giving Gravel our harshest ruling because he botched this fact so badly and because it’s such an important one to get right. It’s something of a popular myth that most of the people in jail or prison are black, so to hear a presidential candidate make the false claim with such authority should not be overlooked. It also is worth noting that the 2.3 million figure that Gravel got right comes from the very same Bureau of Justice report that shows how wrong he was about the incarceration of black people. He should have kept reading.

D
By
David DeCamp
Staff Writer, Tampa Bay Times
August 30, 2007

Truth-o-meter Ruling

Pants on Fire!

Statement

"In 1972, we had a 179,000 human beings in jail in this country. Today, it's 2.3-million, and 70 percent of them are black, African-American."

 

Context

a debate at Howard University.

Speaker/Target

Speaker: Mike Gravel

Statement Date

June 28, 2007
Our Sources

Bureau of Justice Statistics Bulletin, "Prison and Jail Inmates at Midyear 2006," June 2007

Sourcebook of Criminal Justice Statistics, U.S. Department of Justice and State University of New York at Albany

Factcheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center

Translations

Language: en

More by This Author

Latest Fact Checks