Model T got better mileage than SUVs

President Barack Obama lamented the nation’s dependence on foreign oil when visiting an electric car testing center in California on March 19, 2009.

“The problem is that, for decades, we have avoided doing what must be done as a nation to turn challenge into opportunity,” Obama said. “As a consequence, we import more oil today than we did on 9/11. The 1908 Model T earned better gas mileage than a typical SUV sold in 2008. And even as our economy has been transformed by new forms of technology, our electric grid looks largely the same as it did half a century ago.”

We’ve written about Obama’s positions on

imported oil

and the

electric grid

before. But the Model T gets better mileage than an SUV? Really?

To answer this question, we first wanted to look at the mileage for “a typical SUV sold in 2008.”

There are many ways to slice and dice fuel efficiency numbers, and looking up the mileage for your

own particular vehicle

is far easier than deciding on mileage for a “typical SUV.” But the Environmental Protection Agency found that light trucks — the class of vehicle to which SUVs belong — averaged 18.1 miles per gallon for model year 2008. The most efficient SUVs do much better than that — a Jeep Compass gets 23 mpg in the city and 28 on the highway — but Obama said “typical.”

To find out what a Model T averaged, we consulted Bob Casey, author of

The Model T: A Centennial History

, and the curator of transportation at the Henry Ford Museum in Dearborn, Mich. (The museum is named for Ford but independent of the Ford Motor Co.)

He said the best estimate for a Model T’s mileage is 20 miles per gallon, though it might be able to get 25 under the right conditions.

So technically Obama is right.

But his implication is that we haven’t gotten more fuel efficient in 100 years. And that’s a reach.

Let’s look at the differences between today’s SUVs and the Model T of 1908.

To start with, Casey said, Model Ts reached top speeds of only 40 miles an hour. They guzzled motor oil, about a quart a month. The original tops were made of canvas, and they had no heating or cooling systems. They also had none of the safety features of modern cars: no bumpers, no air bags, no seat belts, no antilock breaks.

The cars had large, skinny wheels to more easily clear the obstacles on rocky, rutted roads. Corner them too fast and they could tip over. And if you crashed, the windshield would usually shatter into sharp, jagged pieces that could slice you to ribbons.

“The government would not allow anyone to sell Model Ts today because they’re so unsafe,” Casey said. “It’s a car that no one would use on a regular basis today. It’s not a fair comparison.”

We agree that the two cars are totally different. But Obama was careful in the way he phrased his statement: “The 1908 Model T earned better gas mileage than a typical SUV sold in 2008.”  As long as you don’t consider any factors other than mileage, he’s right. We rate his statement Mostly True.

By

Angie Drobnic Holan

Former Editor-in-Chief

March 19, 2009

Truth-o-meter Ruling

Mostly True

Statement

"The 1908 Model T earned better gas mileage than a typical SUV sold in 2008."

Context

remaks made at an electric car testing center

Speaker/Target

Speaker: Barack Obama

Statement Date

March 19, 2009